by Cynthia Hand
Published by: HarperTeen
Form: Purchased eBook via Kobo
Big Themes: Angels, Destiny, Love Triangle, Family, College
Review of Unearthly
Review of Hallowed
Some minor spoilers for earlier books in the summary, but I did NOT include spoilers in the actual review.
This book begins after the death of a loved one and at the start of Clara’s freshman year of college. Clara, Angela, and Christian are all having new visions. They can’t figure out what their visions are telling them, so they focus on navigating college life. Clara tries to move on and forget about Tucker, but even when she’s around Christian… it’s challenging to forget her first love.
The angel mythology that Hand created for this series is so excellent. I’m sad this is the last book because I want more of this world she’s created. In the first book, I was skeptical about Hand’s world-building. I didn’t understand the visions or what a purpose was. But that’s because Clara didn’t understand yet.
And now, having finished the series and seen Clara’s growing understanding of her purpose as an angel, I can say that Cynthia Hand does a marvelous job of tackling a topic of having a “purpose” in life. This was one of my favorite parts of the series: seeing how everything fit together and how the visions played into each character’s choices and destiny.
Bonus: Angels have awesome abilities. They make logistical sense, and we see them in action in Boundless. There’s some awesome angel training scenes.
I was really surprised at how much action and suspense was in this book. I had a moment where I thought that surely I was at the end of the book, but then I wasn’t! I’m always a big fan of conflict and tension and this book delivered on that.
One of the things I praised highly about Hallowed was Clara’s relationship with her mom. It’s so refreshing to see positive parental relationships in a YA book. I’m not saying Clara doesn’t have conflict with her parents, but it’s clear that they love each other and can talk to each other. This book continues the positive parental bonds by giving us more of Clara’s dad. And interestingly, Clara’s dad still felt quite dad-like despite being an angelic being.
There’s also a great subplot with Clara’s brother that further shows that family bonds are important. While their sibling relationship is rocky, it’s also clear that they love each other. It reminded me of my own relationship with one of my brothers, where we feel this need to compete with each other and be right all the time.
Gosh. What can I say that won’t spoil anything? Some people are very disappointed with how things ended. And I can understand where they are coming from. With a love triangle, readers can’t help but predict and imagine how something might turn out. I think I could have ultimately been happy with Clara choosing either Christian or Tucker. I was a big fan of Tucker after Unearthly. However, both the books and other reader’s arguments have also swayed me to see Christian as a good choice for Clara.
Ultimately, I was happy with the book’s ending. I cried. And ultimately was happy. I have read reviews and discussions where people are disappointed with the results of the book’s love triangle. But I can’t deny that my emotional reaction upon completing the book was joy and satisfaction. I understand other’s issues with the ending, and do wonder if I could have been equally happy if Cynthia Hand had written the love triangle differently.
I did not expect to enjoy this series as much as I did. The books read like contemporary novels with great world-building based in angel mythology. I would have readily continued this series past three books, and will miss the world and characters that Cynthia Hand created. I give this final book in the series five stars.
I'm so happy that you loved this series so much! I agree that the idea of the angels' Purpose is one of the most fascinating parts of these books. I also love the importance this author places on Clara's family, very refreshing in YA. I will admit to being very disappointed by the end of this book. It is less to do with who she picks, but more about how she goes about it. As well as the 'resolution' for the one not chosen. I'm still distraught over it. But I agree, overall a fantastic series.
Wow, high praise! It's always nice when you end up liking a book more than you had expected! I still need to read this series myself – I think I was a little reluctant because it was an angel book and I'm not usually a fan – and now that all three books are out and most people seem to be pretty satisfied with how the ending turned out, I'm ready to go ahead with it! One thing that really sticks with me when I read reviews for this series is that everyone seems to mention how great Clara's relationship with her mother is. And I know I would really appreciate that because how rare is it in YA that you see such a relationship? VERY rare. So I am probably looking forward to that aspect the most. Though I am pretty curious what Team I'll end up on, as well!
I've got the first one on my kindle and I think I will probably take the time to read it soon…